-Cross examination of Williams-
Ques-At 6:31:09s telephone entry showed lizard’s phone in Caymanas North
Ques- At 7:02:23 telephone entry showed Lizard’s phone at Cedar Grove
Ans- Yes (There was an argument as to where Cedar Grove is and it was confirmed that it is in Portmore)
Ques- At 7:04:34 lizard was still in Cedar Grove initiating call
Ques- So sir at this time are you sure nothing happened to Lizard
Ans-I cannot say
Ques- Lizard’s phone never registered on Manning’s Hill Road cell site at all during your analysis
Ques-Up to 7:26:45 phone ascribed to Lizard as being active
Ques- Even then lizard’s phone was not associated w cell site on Kartel”s phone
Ans- He was in cell vicinity
**Pierre Rodgers repeated question. Witness then answered yes**
Ques- You associated particular CGI which covered section of Kartel”s house
**Witness said from Kartel”s house he was able to pick up CGI – 40786 and 40783**
Rodgers quizzed police witness on whether he picked up CGI 40781 from Kartel”s house
Ans-would have to check back collection data
Rodgers – thought u said u only saw 2 CGI. Could there’ve been more
-Rodgers suggested to witness ‘u did a little manipulation to support police theory of case’
Ans- I am a professional and transparent
Ques-Are you aware that 7:52:16 Kartel”s phone reg’d on Manning’s Hill. Rd
Ques- Are you aware there’s a letter from St. Andrew’s Hospital saying Kartel was there from 7:48pm
Ans- Not aware
**Witness presented letter**
Rodgers- You agree that 7:52:16 is the only entry on ur records that puts Kartel anywhere in burnt out house range?
Rodgers suggested to witness ‘u r saying what u have to to try and secure a conviction’
Ans– ‘I am a professional. I speak neither for or against the accused’
Ques- At 10:26:27 where did Kartel”s phone register
Ans- Grants Pen
-Cross examination of Det Sgt Linton who is at MOCA since June 2012-
He testified to have received training from several countries in cyber crime & digital forensics
Trained in Syria, Washington by the FBI and US secret service , duties include conduct cyber crimes investigations, id sources of digital evidence,conduct digital evidence acquisition, exam and analysis to prove/ not cases against accused
On August 3, 2011 Det Sgt Linton was at cyber crimes lab., Corporal Pinnock of Flying Squad visited lab , Corporal Pinnock handed several items to Corporal Shawn Howard in presence of Linton.
1st phone was -I Phone IMEI recorded. Also contained micro SIM.
2nd phone- BB Torch 9800 IMEI noted. No SIM card or battery
3rd phone – BB torch 9800 BB pin noted. SIM card and IMEI as well plus SD card affixed in slot embedded in phone
4th phone – BB 9930 SIM and IMEI noted
Judge admitted 3 /4 phones into evidence. Defence objected admission of 1 saying phone was being used while in police care.
The defense furthered its objection by saying the use of the phone while in police care would affect integrity of instrument. The Judge over- ruled against Defense and agreed to allow audio and video recordings from almost all of the phones, excluding a Blackberry 9930. The phone was not admitted because the information contained in it did not match the information by the other two witnesses. Tomorrow’s evidence will be presented by Sgt Linton . It is said that the video evidence may contain one of two scenarios one could be a hacking of Clive Williams or where his throat was slashed and a block used to bash in his head. Stay chooned!!